ITK/Release 4/Refactor Numerical Libraries/Inventory/Fourier Transforms: Difference between revisions

From KitwarePublic
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
* FFTW - as a configuration time option
* FFTW - as a configuration time option


When using the VXL code that is shipped with ITK, the FFT operations are '''very slow'''.
When using the VXL code that is shipped with ITK, the FFT operations are '''very slow'''. In addition, the VXL FFT produces the full complex output image when operating on a real image instead of producing only the non-redundant half of the image as FFTW does. The ITK filter providing access to VXL's forward FFT can crop the output image to produce output consistent with FFTW, but this is computationally wasteful.


FFTW is a lot faster, but it is licensed under GPL and can not be included as part of the ITK distribution.
FFTW is a lot faster, but it is licensed under GPL and can not be included as part of the ITK distribution.
Line 192: Line 192:
Options that have been considered:
Options that have been considered:


* INTEL Library
* INTEL MKL Library
* AMD Core Math Library (ACML)
 
 
== MKL ==
 
Requires commercial license for distribution
 
== ACML ==
 
Does not require commercial license for distribution

Latest revision as of 16:01, 9 December 2011

The Problem

Functionalities

ITK obtains Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) functionalities from

  • VXL - as software included as third party library
  • FFTW - as a configuration time option

When using the VXL code that is shipped with ITK, the FFT operations are very slow. In addition, the VXL FFT produces the full complex output image when operating on a real image instead of producing only the non-redundant half of the image as FFTW does. The ITK filter providing access to VXL's forward FFT can crop the output image to produce output consistent with FFTW, but this is computationally wasteful.

FFTW is a lot faster, but it is licensed under GPL and can not be included as part of the ITK distribution.

To choose between these two options you use, at CMake configuration time, the following variables

  • USE_FFTWF to use the float version of FFTW
  • USE_FFTWD to use the double version of FFTW
  • USE_SYSTEM_FFTW to use an FFTW library installed in your system

Architecture

  • The current code is *NOT* multi-threaded...

Where is the Code

ITK classes that provide FFT filters can be found in the Module: 

   ITK/Modules/Filtering/FFT

They include

  • itkFFTShiftImageFilter.h
  • itkFFTWForwardFFTImageFilter.h
  • itkFFTWInverseFFTImageFilter.h
  • itkForwardFFTImageFilter.h
  • itkInverseFFTImageFilter.h
  • itkVnlForwardFFTImageFilter.h
  • itkVnlInverseFFTImageFilter.h
  • vnl_fft_3d.h


VXL

Code

The FFT code in VXL is in the directory 

 ITK/Modules/ThirdParty/VNL/src/vxl/core/vnl/algo

and include the following files

  • vnl_fft_1d.h
  • vnl_fft_1d.txx
  • vnl_fft_2d.h
  • vnl_fft_2d.txx
  • vnl_fft_base.h
  • vnl_fft_base.txx
  • vnl_fft.cxx
  • vnl_fft.h
  • vnl_fft_prime_factors.h
  • vnl_fft_prime_factors.txx


It seems that VXL ultimately calls FFT functions from FORTRAN 

  CALL GPFA(A,B,TRIGS,INC,JUMP,N,LOT,ISIGN,NIPQ,INFO)

in the file 

  vnl_fft.h

Conditions

Image Size

The code accepts images whose number of pixels along every dimension is a multiple of powers of the following prime numbers:

  • 2
  • 3
  • 5

That is, it should be an expression such as 

   2^P * 3^Q * 5^R

Image Dimensions

  • Implementations are available for 1D and 2D in VXL.
  • ITK added a 3D instantiation outside of VXL

Benchmark Test

Quick Tests

Quick Test that verify correctness are available here: 

  ITK/Release/Modules/Filtering/FFT/test

They can run the following 

 Test #1: itkVnlFFTTest
 Test #2: itkFFTShiftImageFilterTestOdd0
 Test #3: itkFFTShiftImageFilterTestOdd1
 Test #4: itkFFTShiftImageFilterTestEven0
 Test #5: itkFFTShiftImageFilterTestEven1

Longer Tests

More demanding tests are available here 

  ITK/Release/Examples/Filtering/test

and can be run with 

  ctest  -R FFT   -VV

they are 

 Test #67: FFTImageFilterTest
 Test #68: FFTDirectInverseTest
 Test #69: FFTImageFilterTest2
 Test #70: FFTImageFilterTest3

Best Tests

The most convenient code for benchmarking is in 

 ITK/Examples/Filtering/

They are

  • FFTDirectInverse2.cxx : This one uses FFTW
  • FFTDirectInverse.cxx  : This one uses VXL

Notice that you still have to change the CMake variables at configuration time to switch from one to the other.

The executables of these tests end up in the binary directory: 

  ITK/bin

with the executable name 

  FFTDirectInverse

You can run it as 

 FFTDirectInverse   inputImage  outputImage

For example 

 FFTDirectInverse   mosaic_im100010_05.png    FFT_mosaic_im100010_05.png

The output image is the result of doing Forward Fourier Transform followed by an Inverse Fourier Transform, so in principle it the output image should look just like the input image.

Large Images

Moderate

Very Large

Large images for testing can be found here:

In particular:

  • mosaic_im100010_05.png

This is an image of size 

  8768 x 8640

That FFT expand to 

 16384 x 16384

Doing Direct + Inverst FFT in this image takes 

 262.38s user 4.14s system 102% cpu 4:20.20 total

in a computer with a processor: 

Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5520  @ 2.27GHz

This machine is a quad-core, but... the code is using only one core. This particular machine also has 24 GB of RAM

Options

Options that have been considered:

  • INTEL MKL Library
  • AMD Core Math Library (ACML)


MKL

Requires commercial license for distribution

ACML

Does not require commercial license for distribution

Retrieved from "https://public.kitware.com/Wiki/index.php?title=ITK/Release_4/Refactor_Numerical_Libraries/Inventory/Fourier_Transforms&oldid=44457"