[IGSTK-Users] Viewer Problem due to TransformPhysicalPointToIndex

Fucang Jia jiafucang at asisz.com
Sun Jun 18 21:55:38 EDT 2006


Hi Patrick,

Thank you very much!

The problem of the app depends on the loaded dataset, maybe the spacing, origin
combination trigger the problem.  The axial and coronal view will also have this 
problem. I will send you a CT model DICOM data which will demonstrate this problem.

Thanks!

Fucang
  



On 2006-06-19 09:36:22 Patrick Cheng
Subject:    Re: [IGSTK-Users] Viewer Problem due to TransformPhysicalPointToIndex

Hi  Fucang,

Thank  you  very  much  for  your  patience  and  detailed  report  including
the  video  you  send  to  me.

I  am  sorry  that  I  didn't  look  carefully  enough  on  this.  I  tested  it
carefully  on  axial  view,  and  very  briefly  on  the  other  two  views
windows.  Now  I  do  realize  that  the  sagittal  view  still  has  the  old
problem.

This  is  a  very  interesting  bug.  I  wonder  why  it  only  shows  in  the
sagittal  view.  I  will  take  a  close  look  into  it.  I  will  get  back  to
you  ASAP.

Thank  you,

Patrick

Fucang  Jia  wrote:
>  Hi  Patrick,
>    
>  I  synchronized  the  IGSTK  and  Sandbox  cvs  and  recompiled  it  from  scratch.
>  The  DrawPickedPoint  is  using  continuous  index  now.
>    
>  But  I  can  reproduce  the  problem  with  the  executable  you  sent  me.  I  just  
>  sent
>  you  an  animation    to  picture  this  problem.
>    
>  Thanks  a  lot!
>    
>  Fucang
>    
>  ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>  On  2006-06-19  02:50:55  Patrick  Cheng
>  Subject:        Re:  [IGSTK-Users]  Viewer  Problem  due  to  
>  TransformPhysicalPointToIndex
>    
>  Hi    Fucang,
>    
>  I    fixed    the    problem    in    the    IGSTK    main    repository,    by    adding
>  TransformPhysicalPointToContinuousIndex()    function,    into    the
>  igstkImageSpatialObject    class.
>    
>  But    the    example    application    you    are    running    is    in    the    Sandbox.
>    
>  You    might    need    to    check    on    two    things:
>    
>  First,    after    you    update    the    IGSTK    main    repository,    you    have    to  
>    CMake
>  the    Sandbox    again,    this    way,    the    Sandbox    will    get    the    latest  
>    source
>  from    main    repository,
>    
>  Second,    you    have    updated    the    FourViewsTrackingWithCT    application    in
>  the    Sandbox.    You    can    double    check    by    looking    into    the
>  DrawPickedPoint()    function    in    the    FourViewsTrackingWithCT    .cxx    file.
>  See    whether    it's    using    the    continuous    index.
>    
>  I    will    send    you    the    executables    in    another    separate    email,    because
>  this    email    goes    to    the    mailing    list.
>    
>  Patrick
>    
>    
>    
>  Fucang    Jia    wrote:
>     >    Hi    Patrick,
>     >        
>     >    Thank    you    very    much!
>     >        
>     >    But    I    am    not    keep    clicking    on    the    same    point.    Would    you  
>    like    to    share    me    
>     >    with
>     >    a    Win32    executable    FourViewsTrackingWithCT    app    for    me    to  
>    have    a    test?
>     >            
>     >    Thanks!
>     >        
>     >    Fucang
>     >        
>     >    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>     >    On    2006-06-18    06:10:51    Patrick    Cheng
>     >    Subject:                Re:    [IGSTK-Users]    Viewer    Problem    due    to    
>     >    TransformPhysicalPointToIndex
>     >        
>     >    Hi        Fucang,
>     >        
>     >    I        guess        the        problem        is        you        keep        clicking        on  
>        the        same        point:    
>     >        The        first
>     >    time        you        click        on        a        point,        vtk's        z        buffer      
>    store        the        value,    
>     >        where        the
>     >    ray        intersects        with        the        image        plane.        but        NOTICE  
>        here,        we        put    
>     >        an        sphere
>     >    on        that        clicking        point,        if        you        do        not        moving  
>        the        mouse,        the    
>     >        second
>     >    time        you        click        again,        it        actually        will        return      
>    the        point        on    
>     >        the        sphere
>     >    you        have        clicked.        that's        why        the        slice        is      
>    still        jumping.        if    
>     >        you        move
>     >    you        mouse        a        little        bit,        and        click        on        the      
>    same        image        plane,        it
>     >    shouldn't        have        an        jumping,        i        have        tested        here      
>    without        any        problem.
>     >        
>     >    By        default,        all        the        spatial        object        in        the      
>    view        is        pickable        in    
>     >        IGSTK.
>     >        
>     >    Patrick
>     >        
>     >    Fucang        Jia        wrote:
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Hi        Patrick,
>     >           >                
>     >           >        I        found        that        another        vtk        dlls        exists        in  
>        the        default        path,    
>     >        which        
>     >           >        cause        the        fltk        app        can        not        execute,        when
>     >           >        I        copy        the        compiled        vtk        dlls        into        the      
>    path        of        fltk        app,    
>     >        which        works        well.
>     >           >                
>     >           >        But        on        the        slice        index        jumping        problem,      
>    it        seems        that        it    
>     >        exists.        If        you        
>     >           >        launch        the        app
>     >           >        FourViewTrackingWithCT        compiled        in        debug        mode(      
>    I        have        not    
>     >        tried        in        
>     >           >        release        mode),
>     >           >        and        load        dataset        IGSTK/Testing/Data/Input/E000192
>     >           >        then        let        left        mouse        click        on        the      
>    sagittal        view        plane,        you    
>     >        will        see        that.        
>     >           >        I        first        change        the        sagittal
>     >           >        index        to        511,        then        click        once,        the      
>    index        is        511,        then        I    
>     >        click        it        again,        
>     >           >        the        index        changes        to        510.
>     >           >        When        I        continue        click        left        mouse        on        it,  
>        it        will        change        to    
>     >        509,        508,        ...        
>     >           >        When        it        change        to        464,        it
>     >           >        will        never        change.        When        I        change        the      
>    sagittal        slice        to    
>     >        another        slice,        
>     >           >        then        click,        the        slice        changes
>     >           >        again.
>     >           >                
>     >           >        I        found        this        is        not        due        to      
>    TransformPhysicalPointToIndex    
>     >        function,        but        
>     >           >        in        igstkView.cxx
>     >           >                                                                                                      
>    m_PointPicker-       >GetPickPosition(        data        );
>     >           >        which        compute        z        buffer        depth        from      
>    vtkOpenGLRenderWindow.cxx
>     >           >        int        vtkOpenGLRenderWindow::GetZbufferData(        int        x1,  
>        int        y1,        int    
>     >        x2,        int        y2,
>     >           >                                                                                                                                  
>                                                                                                                                                  
>            
>     >                                                                        float*        z_data        )
>     >           >                glReadPixels(        x_low,        y_low,
>     >           >                                                                                                                                  
>        width,        height,
>     >           >                                                                                                                                  
>        GL_DEPTH_COMPONENT,        GL_FLOAT,
>     >           >                                                                                                                                  
>        z_data        );
>     >           >                
>     >           >        I        add        a        line
>     >           >                        std::cout       <       <"z_data        is        "       <       <*z_data      
>   <       <std::endl;
>     >           >                
>     >           >        when        I        click        the        mouse        at        one        position,  
>        the        z_data    
>     >        changes.        I        think        this        
>     >           >        may        be        the        cause.        But
>     >           >        I        can        not        figure        out        why        now.
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Thanks!
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Fucang
>     >           >                
>     >           >                
>     >           >      
>    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>     >           >        On        2006-06-15        22:55:33        Patrick        Cheng
>     >           >        Subject:                                Re:        [IGSTK-Users]        Viewer      
>    Problem        due        to        
>     >           >        TransformPhysicalPointToIndex
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Hi                Fucang,
>     >           >                
>     >           >        1.                You                should                update                both              
>    IGSTK                and            
>     >        IGSTKSandbox                (bug                fix                is        
>     >           >                in                the
>     >           >        IGSTK,                I                have                also                changed              
>    the                example                app            
>     >        in                IGSTKSandbox                to        
>     >           >                use                the
>     >           >        ContinuousIndex)
>     >           >                
>     >           >        2.                You                might                need                to              
>    cmake                the                IGSTKSandbox            
>     >        again,                this                will        
>     >           >                take                the
>     >           >        latest                code                from                IGSTK                to              
>    IGSTKSandbox                build            
>     >        directory,                and        
>     >           >                then                compile
>     >           >        the                IGSTKSandbox.                (You                have                to      
>            run                the                cmake            
>     >        on                IGSTKSandbox        
>     >           >                again,
>     >           >        after                you                update                the                IGSTK)
>     >           >                
>     >           >        I                have                tested                this                on                the  
>                same                platform            
>     >        here,                it                works                out        
>     >           >                fine                here.                If
>     >           >        you                still                have                problem                with          
>        this.                Can                you                be    
>     >                more                specific                on        
>     >           >                the                error
>     >           >        and                difficulty                you                have                encountered?
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Patrick
>     >           >                
>     >           >        Fucang                Jia                wrote:
>     >           >                       >                Hi                Patrick,
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Thank                you                for                your          
>        rapid                reply.
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                But                after                I              
>    synchronized                with                CVS                version,    
>     >                I                found                that        
>     >           >                all                fltk                app                can                
>     >           >                       >                not                run                (                this                app
>     >           >                       >                is                compiled                in                debug      
>            mode,                VC.Net2003            
>     >        fltk-1-1.7                or        
>     >           >                fltk-1.1.12-16-05).
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Then                I                switched                to          
>        VC6                and                compiled                it.    
>     >                But                I                found                that        
>     >           >                jumping                problem                
>     >           >                       >                still                exists.
>     >           >                       >                and                m_CTImageObserver-              
>     >GetCTImage()-               >IsInside(                p    
>     >                )                will        
>     >           >                incorrectly                
>     >           >                       >                report                to                0                when
>     >           >                       >                sagittal                slice                is                0,      
>            so                it                will                report    
>     >                "Picked                point        
>     >           >                outside                image".
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Thanks                !
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Fucang
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                                                
>     >           >                       >            
>     >      
>    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>     >           >                       >                On                2006-06-15                01:10:05              
>    Patrick                Cheng
>     >           >                       >                Subject:                                                                Re:  
>                [IGSTK-Users]                Viewer            
>     >        Problem                due                to                
>     >           >                       >                TransformPhysicalPointToIndex
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Hi                                Fucang,
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                A                                new                            
>     >        TransformPhysicalPointToContinuousIndex(p,index)                        
>     >           >                function                                and                                a
>     >           >                       >                ContinuousIndexType                                is              
>                    being                                added                    
>     >                to                                the                        
>     >           >                ImageSpatialObject's                                API.
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Now                                if                                you          
>                        take                                the                                pick    
>     >                                position                                and                                use                        
>     >           >                the                                continuous                
>     >           >                       >                                index                                to
>     >           >                       >                reslice                                the                              
>    image,                                it                                will                            
>     >        be                                much                                smoother                        
>     >           >                and                                won't                                jump.
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Please                                update                              
>    your                                IGSTK                                main            
>     >                        and                                Sandbox                        
>     >           >                repository                                code.
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Thank                                you,
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Patrick
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                       >                Fucang                                Jia                                wrote:
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                Hi,                  
>                Patrick,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                There              
>                    is                                a                                problem                    
>     >                due                                to                        
>     >           >                TransformPhysicalPointToIndex                
>     >           >                       >                                function,                                which              
>                    
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                belongs          
>                        to                                Bug#                                738,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                but                  
>                it                                seems                                that                            
>     >        this                                critial                                bug                                has        
>     >           >                                not                                been                                fixed.
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                When                  
>                I                                load                        
>     >           >                IGSTK\Sandbox-Release-8\Testing\Data\E000192,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                press              
>                    the                                left                                mouse            
>     >                        button                                on                                the                        
>     >           >                sagittal                                view                                in                      
>            
>     >           >                       >                                               >                              
>    FourViewsTrackingWithCT                                app                            
>     >        continuously,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                then                  
>                the                                index                                changes    
>     >                                little                                bye                                one,                        
>     >           >                when                                the                                index                          
>        of                
>     >           >                       >                                sagittal                                viewer              
>                    
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                was                  
>                changed                                to                                0,                            
>     >        I                                press                                the
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                mouse              
>                    button                                onto                                the            
>     >                        sagittal                                image,                                it                        
>     >           >                says                                "Picked                                point                
>     >           >                       >                                outside                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                image".          
>                        I                                tracked                                this    
>     >                                bug,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                and                  
>                found                                that                                it                            
>     >        is                                due                                to                                index              
>            
>     >           >                round                                up                                problem.
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                For                  
>                example,                                the                                origin    
>     >                                is                                                                -153.6640625,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                the                  
>                spacing                                is                                0.671875
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                the                  
>                physical                                coordinate                            
>     >        is                                16.3203
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                so                      
>            the                                according                                index    
>     >                                is
>     >           >                       >                                               >                              
>    (16.3203+153.6640625)/0.671875                                =                    
>     >                252.9999813953,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                it                      
>            was                                truncated                                to                    
>     >                252.
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                Then                  
>                resliceImage                                function                    
>     >                will                                change                                the                        
>     >           >                orthogonal                                image                
>     >           >                       >                                slice.
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                I                      
>            also                                found                                this                            
>     >        behaviour                                will                                occur                        
>     >           >                when                                certain                                DICOM                
>     >           >                       >                                dataset                                is                      
>            
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                loaded.          
>                        When                                I                                load                    
>     >                other                                DICOM                                dataset,
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                the                  
>                axial                                and                                coronal            
>     >                        slice                                will                                have                        
>     >           >                problem,                                but                                sagittal                
>     >           >                       >                                view                                does                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                not                  
>                change                                when                                mouse            
>     >                        pressed.                                It                                is                        
>     >           >                because
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                that                  
>                certain                                origin                                and    
>     >                                spacing                                parameters                        
>     >           >                trigger                                this                                problem.
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                Thanks!
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                Fucang
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                        
>     >           >            
>     >      
>    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                
>     >           >                       >                                               >                              
>    _______________________________________________
>     >           >                       >                                               >                                IGSTK-Users  
>                                mailing                                list
>     >           >                       >                                               >                              
>    IGSTK-Users at public.kitware.com
>     >           >                       >                                               >                            
>     >        http://public.kitware.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/igstk-users
>     >           >                       >                                
>     >           >                
>     >        
>     >    --        
>     >    Patrick        Cheng                                                                                                          
>                                                                                                                                    
>     >        Work        phone:        202-687-2902
>     >    Software        Engineer                                                                                                  
>                                                                                                            
>     >        Work        fax:                        202-784-3479
>     >    Email:        cheng at isis.georgetown.edu
>     >        
>     >    Imaging        Science        and        Information        Systems        (ISIS)        Center
>     >    Department        of        Radiology,        Georgetown        University      
>    Medical        Center
>     >    2115        Wisconsin        Avenue,        Suite        603,        Washington,        DC,  
>        20007
>     >        
>    
>  --    
>  Patrick    Cheng                                                                                                                      
>    Work    phone:    202-687-2902
>  Software    Engineer                                                                                                      
>    Work    fax:            202-784-3479
>  Email:    cheng at isis.georgetown.edu
>    
>  Imaging    Science    and    Information    Systems    (ISIS)    Center
>  Department    of    Radiology,    Georgetown    University    Medical    Center
>  2115    Wisconsin    Avenue,    Suite    603,    Washington,    DC,    20007
>    

--  
Patrick  Cheng                                                            Work  phone:  202-687-2902
Software  Engineer                                                    Work  fax:      202-784-3479
Email:  cheng at isis.georgetown.edu

Imaging  Science  and  Information  Systems  (ISIS)  Center
Department  of  Radiology,  Georgetown  University  Medical  Center
2115  Wisconsin  Avenue,  Suite  603,  Washington,  DC,  20007
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://public.kitware.com/pipermail/igstk-users/attachments/20060619/ba2704de/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the IGSTK-Users mailing list